One day after school, Sarah Collins (Matreya Scarrwener) and her best friend Nikki Farrow (Chanelle Peloso) go to watch their school's wrestling match where Sarah develops a crush on wrestler and fellow student Rob Tennison (Callan Porter). She is pleasantly surprised to find out that he has started to show a romantic interest in her as well and they start dating. Soon, however, he starts becoming controlling towards Sarah and at one point, during a get-together at Rob's lake house, Sarah's friends pressure her into reading a poem that Rob had texted her and Rob takes her cell phone outside, Sarah follows him out and he throws it at her in anger, breaking it. Rob apologizes, reminds him of how much he loves her, and offers to buy her a new cell phone and they make up. Nikki comes out and from a distance sees a girl living next door and they wave at each other, but the other girl gets scared after seeing Rob behind Nikki and leaves her confused.